While dismantling John Harrisonās pioneering clock Jonathan Betts found evidence he did not work alone as is usually assumed. He also uncovered hidden features like this decorative bird deep inside the mechanism ā check out ³Ł³ó¾±²õĢż²µ²¹±ō±ō±š°ł²ā to see more.
The story of John Harrison the ālone geniusā who solved the problem of finding longitude at sea is in urgent need of a rewrite.
Advertisement
Discoveries made during repairs to Harrisonās first successful āsea clockā ā completed in 1735 ā suggest that others contributed to his pioneering timepieces. āHarrison is always cast as a self-taught lone genius pitted against the establishment. The truth is, that is a great over-simplification,ā says horologist Jonathan Betts of the .
Betts dismantled the device ā called H1 ā after it stopped last year when a connection between a spring and a swinging balance broke. āItās only when you take it apart and have it in your hands that it comes home to you: the story isnāt quite the one thatās told.ā
See a gallery of images of H1 that show what Betts found.
Longitude legend
The John Harrison legend, made famous in 1995 by Dava Sobelās surprise bestseller Longitude, has the country carpenter-turned-clockmaker designing and building a series of innovative timepieces that kept near perfect time on long sea voyages ā without any advice or help from others.
At the time, mariners were unable to calculate longitude accurately and hence could not pinpoint their position at sea. Harrisonās fourth marine timekeeper ā ā became the first to qualify for the Ā£20,000 offered by the British Government to whoever cracked the problem, although he spent decades fighting for his money.
Now Betts has uncovered evidence that Harrison was not the lone pioneer the legend would have us believe. While carefully taking apart the 1500 components that make up , he has found signs that the provincial craftsman may have had help from more experienced clockmakers to make some of the more sophisticated parts.
Lost and found
H1 hadnāt stopped since being cleaned in the early 1960s and Betts is only the third person to have taken it apart since , who in 1920 discovered the three large timekeepers H1, H2 and H3, broken and mouldering behind a cabinet at the .
Gould spent years repairing and recreating broken and missing parts ā and it was one of his replacement parts that stopped the clock in late 2008. A thin steel strip that connected one of the clockās springs to a swinging balance had rusted and snapped (see the broken part).
āGouldās repair lasted 80 years, which isnāt bad, but there are no signs of any wear on Harrisonās parts,ā says Betts. Harrison famously designed his clock so that there was no friction between moving parts and it never needed oiling.
Hints of help
While studying the dismantled masterpiece Betts came across features that suggested Harrisonās legend is not quite accurate. āItās always said that he made the parts alone [in rural Lincolnshire] ā except for some help from his brother. But when you look at it, that doesnāt quite add up.ā
For example, H1ās brassworkĀ is too impressive to fit with the legend. āThe received wisdom is that Harrison transferred his considerable woodworking skills to brass but working brass requires different skills,ā says Betts. He may have learnt the techniques by studying expert brassworkers but H1 ā his first brass clock ā doesnāt bear the hallmarks of a beginner, suggesting he probably commissioned someone else to help out.
Neither were H1ās dials all Harrisonās work: the reverse of each bears the words āupwardsā ā an instruction to the engraver. Another clue lies in the , which evens out the pull of the mainspring.
At the time, even the best clocks made in London had fusees wound around with a cord of gut rather than a chain, says Betts. But H1 used chain and was one of the earliest clocks to do so. In fact, it has two fusee chains, each a metre long with each link in five parts, needing up to 2000 components for each chain.
āSpecialised skillā
āMaking them was a very specialised skill, and they were mostly fitted to watches,ā says Betts, āThatās so sophisticated, I find it hard to believe he made this in Barrow on Humber as a loner.ā
He thinks the chains were bought in London and believes that Harrison watched craftsmen at work there, asked their advice, and commissioned their help. āThere was definitely more involvement from other people. What we donāt know is how far it went. People thought he just sat down and made it all by himself. It was surely not like that.ā
Betts has now made a new, non-rusting repair that should last longer than Gouldās. āIām also doing a bit of light dusting, which is more important than it sounds,ā he says. Although H1 shows no wear, it suffers from what Betts calls ācomputer mouse syndromeā ā the accumulation of compacted fluff that eventually jams the rollers in older mechanically operated mice.
One of Harrisonās innovations to avoid friction was to make parts roll over each other with minimal contact, avoiding the need for oil. āOn those parts fluff is mashed to crud and has to be gently scraped off,ā says Betts.
