
AN HIV virus modified to infect monkeys could be a big step forward for HIV research.
The disclosure last month that an experimental vaccine against HIV may not be as effective as first thought highlighted a nagging problem with HIV-vaccine research: that there is no effective way of testing them in animals.
All that could change if the new animal model of HIV is successful. Current primate models use simian immunodeficiency virus (SIV), which is similar but not identical to HIV.
Advertisement
The new model, developed by a team led by virologist at the Aaron Diamond AIDS Research Center (ADARC) in New York, could guide future vaccine trials, drug development and basic research into the virus. “The potential applications are huge,” Hatziioannou says. “It could change the way we do our animal research for HIV and AIDS.” She presented her team’s results at in Boston last month.
Few researchers question the need for better animal models of the HIV virus, which about 33 million people are living with worldwide. In the early days of the AIDS epidemic, HIV therapies were tested on chimpanzees, the virus’s original host. But HIV doesn’t cause disease in chimps and their endangered status limited researchers’ use of them. So they turned to monkeys and SIVs.
Today, labs use two main varieties of SIV: one from sooty mangabeys that causes an AIDS-like disease in macaques, and a hybrid virus called SHIV, which contains a cocktail of HIV genes spliced into SIV (see “The right virus for the job”). “Neither of the models corresponds to what happens with HIV in humans perfectly,” Hatziioannou says. SIV thwarts the monkey immune system in a slightly different way to HIV, and SHIVs use only bits of HIV.
Hatziioannou’s new virus, developed with , also at ADARC, and researchers at the US National Cancer Institute in Frederick, Maryland, is based on two decades of research into how HIV and SIV foil immune systems. The research showed that the viruses work by overcoming two key defence proteins: TRIM5-alpha, which prevents retroviruses such as HIV from shedding their coat once they invade a cell, and APOBEC3G, which stashes itself inside newly formed viruses and sabotages their efforts to reproduce. HIV has learned to counter both of these proteins in humans, and SIVs do the same in monkeys. Yet monkey defences are not fooled by HIV.
Hatziioannou’s breakthrough was to splice into HIV the SIV gene called vif, whose protein is unaffected by monkey APOBEC3G (). The team found that the resultant virus, known as stHIV, causes a disease in pig-tailed macaques (which lack functional TRIM5-alpha) that mimics the early stages of HIV infection. This could make it a more useful tool for testing HIV drugs and vaccines than SIV or SHIV. The team also found that giving monkeys a high dose of antiretroviral drugs before infection with stHIV – a therapy being considered for people at high risk of HIV – prevented them from contracting the virus.
“The spliced virus causes a disease in pig-tailed macaques that mimics early-stage HIV infection”
Hatziioannou’s team cannot rest on these accomplishments, however. Even without drugs, the monkey’s immune system eventually controls the virus and they never develop AIDS.
at the National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases in Bethesda, Maryland, whose team developed a similar HIV model, says more changes will be necessary. “There are a lot of other genes to think about if you really want to come up with a good animal model,” he says.
The right virus for the job
SIV Asian rhesus macaques infected with simian immunodeficiency virus from sooty mangabeys develop something akin to AIDS. This is the most widely used animal model in HIV research, though SIV lacks a protein that HIV uses to thwart the human immune system.
SHIV SHIVs are hybrid viruses created by splicing a handful of HIV genes into the SIV genome. While these allow the testing of human vaccines in monkeys, some strains appear suspiciously easy for vaccines to defeat: a vaccine made by Merck that looked promising in a SHIV model failed in large-scale human trials.
stHIV In this new approach (main story), an HIV virus is redesigned to infect monkeys by adding one or two SIV genes. If it succeeds it could be used to test nearly all HIV drugs and vaccines, though it doesn’t cause full-blown AIDS and works best in pig-tailed macaques, which are not widely available to researchers.