鶹ý

Science pervades western thought – but should it?

Philosopher Paul Feyerabend's posthumously published The Tyranny of Science takes issue with the dominance of scientism, but suggests few alternatives

IN THIS posthumously published book, the maverick philosopher of science Paul Feyerabend questions the dominance of abstract, theoretical, objectivist science over more human modes of thought. He also targets society’s adoption of scientism, the belief that science has the answer to all meaningful questions.

Feyerabend’s strategy is to take some hallowed idea – for instance, that the success of science is due to observation and experiment – and scrutinise its origins. In this case, he finds the roots of the idea in the philosophy of the ancient Greeks. After assessing their reasoning, he finds the idea “optional” in his value system, since he gives more weight to stories than arguments. Sadly, despite important remarks along the way, Feyerabend’s critique of scientism, and his proposed alternatives, remain unfocused and not well worked out.

The Tyranny of Science

Paul Feyerabend, edited by Eric Oberheim

Polity Press

Topics: Books and art

More from 鶹ý

Explore the latest news, articles and features