鶹ý

Don’t give up: The inventor of 3D printing tells his story

How Chuck Hull invented 3D printing: a tale of persistence, ingenuity and winning when you didn't come first
Chuck Hull
Chuck Hall
Heinz Troll/European Patent Office

Around the world, thousands of people who are missing limbs are wearing custom-fitted replacements. In operating theatres, surgeons are using 3D replicas of their patients’ bodies to guide operations. That’s the kind of thing that makes Chuck Hull very, very happy – because he invented the technology that made it possible. “I’ve been the most surprised and impressed by the advances 3D printing has enabled in healthcare,” Hull says. “It’s an amazing feeling to contribute to saving and improving lives on such a fundamental level.”

Thirty years ago that was unthinkable. Making things like prosthetic limbs – or even plastic widgets – was notoriously difficult. “Every engineer knew how tedious it was,” Hull says. “You would design a part and make blueprints that you give to a designer. Then you need a machinist. Then, finally, you’d go to the injection moulder.” And if it wasn’t right, you had to go through the whole process again. Manufacturers were desperate for a better way. “Nobody had a solution for this – and that was the point of 3D printing,” Hull says. “The idea was simply to prototype plastic parts. It doesn’t sound very imaginative given how exciting 3D printing has become.”

Hull is being typically modest: back in 1983 his idea was a flash of inspiration. At the time, he was working for a small US company using high-intensity UV light to set, or cure, liquid plastic into solid. One of its products was a coating for a table. “At some point it occurred to me that we were curing really thin pieces of plastic,” Hull says. “I thought, maybe there was some way I could stack up these sheets to create prototype parts.”

If he could make it work, it would slash production times from months to days. “I went to the head of the company all excited, saying, ‘Hey, we’ve got to work on this’.”

He didn’t get very far. Despite Hull’s enthusiasm, his boss was reluctant to gamble valuable resources on a future in layered plastic. But Hull kept arguing his case. “I was confident that I could figure out how to do it,” he says. Eventually, his boss agreed to let him have an empty lab at the back of the building. But he couldn’t use it in company time. He had to work on the idea at evenings and weekends.

He started with the motors found in pen plotters – machines that draw things like building plans – and programmed their motion on a primitive computer using BASIC. It was laborious work. “You had to envision it in your head and program in, line by line, the routine for the shapes you wanted,” he recalls.

To make the objects themselves, he focused two UV lights on a vat of liquid plastic and used two motors to guide the light across its surface, solidifying a sliver of plastic into a flat shape. The third motor then lowered the solidified piece, submerging it in liquid plastic again, ready to add the next layer.

At first, Hull struggled to get the layers to stick and the shapes to hold together. “I made lots of junk,” he says.

Night after night he persevered. Slowly the shapes improved, until he finally made something he had designed – though considering what 3D printers can make now it was a modest triumph.

“The first actual part I made was just a small cup shape.” But it was enough. The idea was ready to take to the next level. “We got the patent application in and our patent attorney was all excited. He thought it could be a real breakthrough. A number of the engineers in the company were excited about it too.” Hull was soon back in his boss’s office again, pushing his idea. It was time for the company to commercialise stereolithography, he said.

It didn’t fly. Pressing ahead would mean a big investment in time and resources, and his boss decided it wasn’t worth the risk.

It was probably the right decision, albeit for the wrong reasons. What neither of them knew at the time was that somebody had got there before them. Just three weeks earlier, a team at the French General Electric Company led by Alain Le Méhauté had filed a patent for virtually the same process.

“When you’re trying to do something new, very few people see the wisdom of it“

With no patent and no backing, Hull’s dream was over. He can be philosophical about it now. “The history of technology tells you that when somebody invents something, you can be pretty sure somebody else in the world is close to it too,” Hull says.

But coming first is not the same as winning. Le Méhauté’s bosses turned out to be even more risk-averse than his. The General Electric Company abandoned the patent application, seeing no potential in it. Hull’s patent was approved and he decided to go it alone. In 1986 he set up his own company, 3D Systems.”When you’re trying to do something new, very few people see the wisdom of it,” Hull says. “But I’m a pretty positive person. I’d hear all the naysayers and it wouldn’t affect me.”

The first people to see the potential were automobile manufacturers, who at the time were lagging badly behind their Japanese rivals. “They were really enthused about what the technology could do for their company, and so we were soon making equipment, training them in how to use it and install it.”

3d printer
From humble beginnings:the first machine built by 3D systems
3DSystems

Since then, 3D printing has grown and grown. Several methods have been invented, and 3D scanners make it possible to recreate an object exactly. Apps are being developed that will let you scan an item with . And it’s not just for plastic any more – the technology has been adapted for all kinds of materials, even chocolate. Last year, private exploration company SpaceX used 3D printing to build a rocket engine. Perhaps the most impressive material, though, is human cells. It is now possible to print replacement blood vessels, skin and heart tissue, and 3D-printed organs are undergoing their first clinical trials. It’s a long way from the small cup Hull printed 33 years ago.

Profile

Chuck Hull is founder and CTO of 3D Systems, based in Rock Hill, South Carolina. He patented the stereolithography process in 1986

This article appeared in print under the headline “The day the world became 3D”

Topics: 3d printing / medical technology