Âé¶¹´«Ã½

How gardeners can help plant-eating insects instead of killing them

Aphids and other garden foes often make us reach for pesticides, but a wildlife rethink could be in order. With many insects in decline, we should be planting to lure invertebrates to our gardens, says Clare Wilson

AS MOST of the UK recovers from a frigid April and a soggy May, its gardens are starting to perk up. That means so are caterpillars, aphids such as greenflies, and other plant-feeding invertebrates generally seen as the gardener’s foes.

A common reaction to seeing prized plants covered with bugs is to reach for the pesticide spray. But we should temper that instinct, says , principal entomologist at the UK Royal Horticultural Society. Many invertebrate species in the UK and elsewhere are in decline, and gardens can be a haven – the UK’s home gardens collectively add up to an area larger than the country’s official nature reserves.

You might think there is no shortage of aphids, but they are food for bigger insects, such as ladybirds, lacewings and wasps, not to mention blue tits. While gardens are a much understudied ecological resource, suggests they can support hundreds of invertebrate species, including at least two insects in decline in the UK: two-spot ladybirds and, in the south, stag beetles.

Most synthetic pesticides kill aphids’ insect predators too – and aphids tend to bounce back faster than their predators, requiring repeated spraying. If you must spray, try to use organic, soap-based products, which tend to be less harmful to predators – though they aren’t completely non-toxic, says Salisbury. He doesn’t advise home-made soap solutions as they haven’t been tested for their effects on plants or wildlife.

There are other ways you can encourage invertebrates into your garden, according to a . These include denser planting (although spiders love bare spots between plants) and choosing British species. The researchers compared how many invertebrates could be supported by three types of typical garden planting scheme: native British plants, “near-native†plants (defined as those from the same genus found in the northern hemisphere) and exotics, or those from the southern hemisphere.

Native plants were the best at supporting ground and foliage-dwelling invertebrates, but the difference wasn’t that big. For example, 18 exotic plants supported the same number of bugs as 17 near-native and 14 native plants of the same size.

The exception was for , such as honeybees, wild bees and hoverflies. These appreciated the exotic flower beds in late summer and autumn, when they had more blooms. As a result, the team recommends that UK gardeners focus on native plants with some exotics mixed in to extend the flowering season.

But Salisbury’s main message is that, as far as possible, gardeners should relax about nibbled foliage, aim for a profusion of varied plant species and let the wildlife share their space. “It’s not a garden, it’s a living ecosystem,†he says.

What you need

Lots of plants

No pesticides, especially not synthetic ones

For other projects visit newscientist.com/maker.

Topics: gardening