For decades, researchers have known that the more older brothers a man has, the greater his likelihood of being gay. More recently, this has also been . Now, a modelling study suggests that the latter link could be explained by older sisters being a proxy for their mother previously having multiple pregnancies, some of which may have involved miscarried male embryos. The scientists have stressed, however, that this is just an idea and further research is needed.
Carrying boys during pregnancy is thought to cause an immune response towards specific male proteins involved in fetal brain development, which becomes stronger with successive male pregnancies. If the resulting antibodies enter the brain of a male fetus, they could influence his sexual orientation later on. But that doesn鈥檛 explain the link to older sisters.
One proposed explanation is that older sisters provide clues about a mother鈥檚 reproductive history. The idea goes that the more children a woman has, the more times she has been pregnant, some of which could have ended in miscarriages, including extremely early ones. If male embryos were miscarried, they may have sensitised her immune system against those male proteins. 鈥淚t鈥檚聽nothing more than a possibility聽right聽now,鈥� says at the University of Montpellier in France.
Advertisement
To explore this, Raymond and his colleagues built a model to uncover whether miscarriages could generate an older-sister effect for male sexual orientation. For simplicity, it assumed that all women have the same probability of miscarriage for each pregnancy, says Raymond. In reality, miscarriage risk probably varies among women, even when accounting for age, which should be investigated in further research, he says.
The researchers compared the model鈥檚 predictions with data from eight populations. This suggested that each additional older brother is associated with about a 30 per cent increase in the odds of a man being gay, while each additional older sister is linked to about a 20 per cent increase. The team calculated that between 37 and 58 per cent of fertilised eggs would need to be miscarried to fully explain the older sister association. Information about whether the participating mothers included non-binary people and trans men wasn鈥檛 routinely collected across the eight population datasets.
About in the US, but Raymond says, 鈥渢here鈥檚 huge variation, depending on what you consider a miscarriage鈥�, with some occurring .
This study doesn鈥檛 definitely show that miscarriages explain the older-sister effect, says Raymond. 鈥淚t shows that miscarriage is potentially an important phenomenon to take into account,鈥� he says. 鈥淗owever, it is also possible that the maternal immune hypothesis is not correct, and at this stage, it is not possible to decide.鈥�
at the University of Toronto in Canada, who has also proposed that older sisters could act as a proxy for miscarried male pregnancies, says the study adds weight to his idea. 鈥淚t could have come up with results saying that my hypothesis was basically very unlikely, but it came up with results indicating that, while my hypothesis may not 100 per cent account for the effect of older sisters, we鈥檙e within the realm of what is possible.鈥�
It is also unclear how far a pregnancy may need to progress to trigger the proposed maternal immune response.
found that mothers of gay sons with older brothers had higher levels of antibodies against a Y-chromosome-linked protein involved in brain development called NLGN4Y, compared with mothers of heterosexual sons. at Uppsala University in Sweden has documented the expression of NLGN4Y in , and says its expression probably begins even earlier.
at the University of Melbourne in Australia previously found that . This included linking older siblings to a greater likelihood of a woman entering a same-sex union, which can鈥檛 readily be explained by a maternal immune response to male-specific proteins. This response could be to proteins that aren鈥檛 sex specific, says Kab谩tek.
Sexual orientation probably can鈥檛 be explained through one mechanism. Genetic factors are thought to play a role, with identical twins being more likely to share a sexual orientation than fraternal ones. as an influence.
鈥淚 believe, as do probably most researchers in this area, that there are likely a few different biological causes of homosexuality,鈥� says Blanchard. 鈥淭herefore, evidence in favor of genetic causes, or [hormone-related] causes, neither supports nor undermines evidence for immunological causes.鈥�
bioRxiv
