Âé¶¹´«Ã½

Letters archive

Join the conversation in Âé¶¹´«Ã½'s Letters section, where readers can share their thoughts and opinions on articles and see responses from experts and enthusiasts across a range of science topics. To submit a letter, please see our terms and email letters@newscientist.com


4 August 2021

Canine free-for-all is already here

From Cristián Bonacic, Pontifical Catholic University of Chile

You report that there are around a billion dogs in the world, with up to 85 per cent free to interact with the environment to some degree as feral or street dogs ( 24 July, p 43 ). While your article imagines how dogs might fare in a future without us, a world without responsible …

4 August 2021

Getting to the bottom of race-based medical issues

From Richard Mellish, London, UK

You report that race-based adjustments to diagnostic criteria reflect bad science and should be abolished ( 17 July, p 16 ). Fair enough. But we also often read that this or that medical procedure hasn't been sufficiently validated because the clinical trials involved a limited cohort, for example mostly white people. We also sometimes read …

4 August 2021

Meth-addicted fish may not be at a disadvantage

From Sam Edge, Ringwood, Hampshire, UK

You report that fish addicted to methamphetamines that end up in Czech rivers may have a reduced survival rate. It may not be so ( 17 July, p 20 ). If both predators and prey are equally debilitated, then they will all still be on the same footing and the pollution may not make any …

11 August 2021

So many issues holding up self-driving cars (1)

From Martin Stanley, London, UK

In "Where's my robot car?", Jeff Hecht points out that self-driving cars that stop at every false alarm would cause gridlock ( 31 July, p 45 ). I would add that pedestrians could also learn that they won't need to wait to cross the road in front of fully autonomous vehicles that detect people. Cars …

11 August 2021

So many issues holding up self-driving cars (2)

From David Myers, Commugny, Switzerland

As a postgraduate physics student 50 years ago, I was told by an AI expert that "we shall have machine translation licked in 10 years ". I think we are similarly over-optimistic about the imminent arrival of truly self-driving cars. One problem is software written for ideal conditions. I'll believe that self-driving cars have arrived …

11 August 2021

So many issues holding up self-driving cars (3)

From Robert Maier, Penicuik, Midlothian, UK

Hecht's article omits one potential route to fully autonomous level 4 or 5 driving, namely fully interconnected traffic. If every vehicle, be it driving or stationary, would constantly transmit its actions and position to all vehicles around it, one could achieve a level of mass "awareness" that gets around the shortcomings of stand-alone sensors. Traffic …

11 August 2021

Good reason to double jab everyone and fast (1)

From Rachael Padman, Newmarket, Suffolk, UK

You say countries with many partially vaccinated people and a lot of coronavirus infections (such as the UK) are breeding grounds for new variants of the SARS-CoV-2 virus that may evade antibodies ( 31 July, p 8 and Leader ). On the other hand, you say in your related Leader that lower-income countries will be …

11 August 2021

Good reason to double jab everyone and fast (2)

From Christine Duffill, Southampton, UK

Regarding your Leader, a balance must be struck between "the speediest possible end to the pandemic" and the long-term effects of lockdown restrictions on the mental and physical health of millions. I fail to see how the UK government could have reacted to delta any more safely than it did. The editor writes: If vaccinations …

11 August 2021

There is a reason why food may get less nutritious

From John Radogno, Rohnert Park, California, US

Further to James Wong's look at claims that food is becoming less nutritious, there is reason to think this will occur ( 17 July, p 24 ). Higher levels of carbon dioxide increase plant growth, but as more carbon enters the plant it doesn't bring an increase in essential proteins and minerals, thus diluting the …

11 August 2021

No mystical vitalism, but consciousness may be rare

From Lawrence R. Bernstein, Menlo Park, California, US

Regarding Luce Gilmore's comments on consciousness, the rejection of mystical vitalism doesn't exclude the possibility that consciousness only arises from certain living brains ( Letters, 24 July ). It may be that billions of diverse neurons, having trillions of varied and ever-changing connections carrying constantly modulating signals, bathed in a brew of ions, hormones, enzymes …

Sign up to our weekly newsletter

Receive a weekly dose of discovery in your inbox. We'll also keep you up to date with Âé¶¹´«Ã½ events and special offers.

Sign up
Piano Exit Overlay Banner Mobile Piano Exit Overlay Banner Desktop