Âé¶¹´«Ã½

Letters archive

Join the conversation in Âé¶¹´«Ã½'s Letters section, where readers can share their thoughts and opinions on articles and see responses from experts and enthusiasts across a range of science topics. To submit a letter, please see our terms and email letters@newscientist.com


26 May 2021

Free to question the very idea of free will

From Nigel Tuersley, Wardour, Wiltshire, UK

You looked at superdeterminism, a take on quantum theory that does away with randomness ( 15 May, p 36 ). Objections were raised to it on the grounds that it would deny humans free will. As far as we are aware, nothing in the universe is independent of the cosmos, and what we refer to …

26 May 2021

Let's not be too optimistic about the climate

From Bruce Denness, Niton, Isle of Wight, UK

Michael Le Page reports that the world is "on track to pass the Paris aspirational limit of 1.5°C between 2026 and 2042... to exceed 2°C above its pre-industrial level between the 2040s and 2070s" ( 24 April, p 34 ). He adds: "We aren't heading for the worst-case scenario... could have led to around 5°C …

26 May 2021

Best way to help pigs isn't an AI, but a change of diet

From Greg Billington, Picton, New Zealand

So AI can read emotional states in the facial expressions of cattle and pigs ( 1 May, p 14 ). It is suggested that this technology will enable farmers to improve animal well-being by reducing stressful husbandry. Despite coming from a farming family and having been a hunter for many years, the best possible way …

26 May 2021

Spotted in broad daylight: a playful platypus

From Tony Fist, Norwood, Tasmania, Australia

Far from being strictly nocturnal, I have seen many platypuses active during the day in Tasmania, including a memorable encounter with one splashing in the melting snow near Cradle Mountain ( 8 May, p 41 ).

26 May 2021

Beware offending the mighty palm

From Gary Warburton, Dublin, Ireland

Amid talk of tree sentience, Steve Tunnicliff suggests apologising to an elder tree before cutting it down to avoid its vengeance ( Letters, 15 May ). I have heard of doing the same for a rowan tree. However, it seems to me that it is palm trees we should really worry about, as they are …

2 June 2021

Nature is still better than a surrogate for nature

From Steve Phillips, Brussels, Belgium

In her article on the importance of green spaces in urban areas, Kate Douglas paints a picture of accelerated urbanisation 27 March, p 36 . Much has been made of the advantages of urbanisation, but I would argue that this view is becoming outdated. Yes, connectivity and accessibility remain important, but in the 21st century …

2 June 2021

On the ancient origins of the alphabet

From Daniel Harbour, professor of the cognitive science of language, Queen Mary University of London

To say that mystery glyphs look like "early alphabetic letters" is to say that they look like crude versions of hieroglyphs 24 April, p 15 . Finding such hieroglyphs in Syria 850 years before reliably dated samples of Levantine alphabetic writing might show not that the alphabet is older than previously thought, but that Egypt …

2 June 2021

Why might some black holes survive as minnows?

From Michael Overholt, San Jose, California, US

From 3 April, p 34 You report suggestions that a primordial black hole roughly the size of a grapefruit and several times the mass of Earth is the hypothetical Planet Nine in our solar system, responsible for the orbital alignment of a group of small objects in the Kuiper belt. This leaves me wondering how …

2 June 2021

Quantum determinism over the decades

From Sam Milne, Claygate, Surrey, UK

I enjoyed Michael Brooks's article on superdeterminism 15 May, p 36 . Sabine Hossenfelder and Tim Palmer's idea of a determinate quantum universe warrants comparison with thinking in the 1950s. Back then, David Bohm argued for a deterministic model of quantum theory that allows for probabilities to arise from certain "hidden" details, given a universe …

2 June 2021

Other barriers on the road to eradicating malaria

From Carole Mooney, Blairgowrie, Perthshire, UK

Regarding the work to eradicate malaria 1 May, p 44 . My husband was in Uganda a few years ago, and while talking to village elders in a lakeside area, they told him of their frustration with the bed net roll-out. They said that although families had been issued nets, many used them for fishing. …

Sign up to our weekly newsletter

Receive a weekly dose of discovery in your inbox. We'll also keep you up to date with Âé¶¹´«Ã½ events and special offers.

Sign up
Piano Exit Overlay Banner Mobile Piano Exit Overlay Banner Desktop