Âé¶¹´«Ã½

Letters archive

Join the conversation in Âé¶¹´«Ã½'s Letters section, where readers can share their thoughts and opinions on articles and see responses from experts and enthusiasts across a range of science topics. To submit a letter, please see our terms and email letters@newscientist.com


23 September 2020

A bit of fuzziness isn't a big problem for physics

From Rachael Padman, Cambridge, UK

In "Welcome to the fuzzy-verse", philosopher Eddy Keming Chen misstates the relationship of physics and mathematics ( 5 September, p 36 ). The universe is what it is, and the fundamental laws of physics are really just expressions of the patterns we observe there – they don't explain anything. What they can do is help …

23 September 2020

No time to waste, let's get on with restoring the sky

From John Crook, Napier, New Zealand

I was inspired by Graham Lawton's description of Rob Jackson's plea to restore the atmosphere to its pre-industrial state ( 22 August, p 24 ). We absolutely must do this. Any plan or course of action that falls short of full reinstatement to pre-industrial conditions, with the associated thermal equilibrium of the planet that is …

23 September 2020

Many ways to look at the impact of social contact

From Terry Cannon, Lewes, East Sussex, UK

In his look at the benefits of "social capital", inspired by the pandemic lockdown, David Robson argues that "in recent decades, a raft of research has shown that individuals with richer social worlds tend to have better mental well-being and lower stress, and to perform better at work" ( 15 August, p 32 ). Does …

23 September 2020

On the search for ways to end the pandemic

From Jonathan Watson, London, UK

Could there be an alternative to a coronavirus vaccine to achieve herd immunity if we could come up with a test to predict who would be asymptomatic? Many people would probably fall into this category ( 5 September, p 7 ). They might have something in common other than their underlying good health that could …

23 September 2020

Partial postal voting could yet upset the US election

From Ed Prior, Poquoson, Virginia, US

You report on an analysis that found voting by mail would have little effect on US election results ( 5 September, p 20 ). It seems to assume that Democrats and Republicans would vote by post in similar numbers. In fact, a recent poll indicates that a significantly higher proportion of those who support the …

30 September 2020

Should we jump the gun on vaccination?

From River Axe-the-Tax, Manchester, UK Simon Goodman expresses concern about Russian plans to roll out a coronavirus vaccine without the usual stage III clinical trials, rightly saying that these can help spot harm ( Letters, 19 September ). Similar concerns have to be raised about Donald Trump's desire for a vaccine to be released before …

30 September 2020

Some birds are seen as less fully fledged than others

From Brian Reffin Smith, Berlin, Germany So many of the questions and answers within Eddy Keming Chen's article "Welcome to the fuzzy-verse" seem, perhaps paradoxically given the article's emphasis on mathematics, to be due to human choice, and hence to become impossibly vague ( 5 September, p 36 ). We can choose to think about …

30 September 2020

Why global greening won't keep climate change at bay

From Patrick Davey, Dublin, Ireland Your article explores how the rate of carbon absorption by forests may alter as the climate changes ( 15 August, p 38 ). While I was working in Uganda with Mountains of the Moon University, one of our central projects involved growing roses. We were about 300 metres higher than …

30 September 2020

Perhaps life's origins happened in slow motion

From Jim Ainsworth, Kingsland, Herefordshire, UK As to which came first when life arose – structural integrity, metabolism or reproduction – Michael Marshall explains that it is possible all three happened at once ( 8 August, p 34 ). He adds that metabolism is the trickiest system to account for, since it involves "creating entire …

30 September 2020

A simple explanation for weird baby dinosaurs?

From Paul Wood, Hamilton, New Zealand You report that baby titanosaurs had a sharp horn on their snout, something that was absent in any adult fossils, but offer few possible reasons for this difference ( 5 September, p 20 ). Perhaps it was there to help them break out of their egg, just as birds …

Sign up to our weekly newsletter

Receive a weekly dose of discovery in your inbox. We'll also keep you up to date with Âé¶¹´«Ã½ events and special offers.

Sign up
Piano Exit Overlay Banner Mobile Piano Exit Overlay Banner Desktop