Âé¶¹´«Ã½

Letters archive

Join the conversation in Âé¶¹´«Ã½'s Letters section, where readers can share their thoughts and opinions on articles and see responses from experts and enthusiasts across a range of science topics. To submit a letter, please see our terms and email letters@newscientist.com


19 February 2020

Editor's pick: Reasons why we do and don't live in a simulation (1)

From Andy Howe, Sheffield, UK

In Daniel Cossins's piece "Do we make reality?", philosopher Kelvin McQueen says consciousness may not be exclusive to humans or other complex organisms, but may exist, in a rudimentary form, in inanimate objects ( 1 February, p 34 ). How does that differ from proposing that the wave function collapse, which produces a "real" event, …

19 February 2020

Editor's pick: Reasons why we do and don't live in a simulation (2)

From Carl Zetie, Raleigh, North Carolina, US

In "Can we create reality?", Donna Lu reports the claim by philosopher Nick Bostrom that if there are any simulated universes at all they will vastly outnumber any real ones. So, he says, we probably live in a simulated universe. This argument is fatally self-contradicting. The universe that we live in is enormously more complicated …

19 February 2020

Editor's pick: Reasons why we do and don't live in a simulation (3)

From John Davenport, Kenley, Surrey, UK

Lu suggests that if we live in a simulation it would be switched off if the overlords realised that we knew about it. But it is most likely that the overlords are kids playing in their bedrooms. Our discovery would merely add excitement. The risk arises when they discover girls, boys or whatever, at which …

19 February 2020

Attainment is the best predictor of attainment

From Peter Tymms, Durham, UK

Geneticist Robert Plomin believes genetic testing can help to identify pupils who would benefit from educational interventions, and says a study that found a correlation of 0.4 between polygenic scores and GCSE results supports his stance ( 18 January, p 9 ). Others claim that socio-economic status is a better predictor, though such a strong …

19 February 2020

A gaping lacuna in your coverage of fear of holes

From Hugh Kolb, Logie Coldstone, Aberdeenshire, UK

You report on trypophobia, a fear of holes ( 18 January, p 38 ). I am puzzled that you didn't link this to the image a few pages earlier of rather unpleasant spotty bacterial patterns on agar gels ( p 28 ). Isn't it likely that some people's disgust at spots is related to a …

26 February 2020

The evolution of sexuality and the blind date model (1)

From Peter Mendenhall, Nottingham, UK

Andrew Barron mentions a study that showed that same-sex attraction could be a polygenic trait rather than a monogenic one ( 8 February, p 23) . Either way, as identical twins share the same genes they should have the same sexual orientation if the trait is entirely genetic. But it is known that if one …

26 February 2020

The evolution of sexuality and the blind date model (2)

From Perry Bebbington, Kimberley, Nottinghamshire, UK

Barron considers why same-sex attraction isn't a paradox . His explanation of the evolution of sexuality shares one thing with all other explanations I have seen: it is far too complicated. Sexual reproduction works for species that don't distinguish between mating with their own or the other sex. As long as they sometimes mate with …

26 February 2020

The economics of staring into a simulated universe (1)

From Martin Ellis, London, UK

Donna Lu's account of the suggestion that we may be living in a simulation made me think ( 1 February, p 42 ). If we were, it is possible that time would appear to run slower close to large and complex objects, as the computer we are running on struggles to process all the myriad …

26 February 2020

The economics of staring into a simulated universe (2)

From John King, East Grinstead, West Sussex, UK

Lu reports the concern of philosopher Preston Greene that our present reality might be switched off if we were in danger of discovering that we live in a simulation. This shouldn't be our greatest worry. We should be more anxious lest our simulator overlords find that their research budget has been cancelled, as the experiment …

Sign up to our weekly newsletter

Receive a weekly dose of discovery in your inbox. We'll also keep you up to date with Âé¶¹´«Ã½ events and special offers.

Sign up
Piano Exit Overlay Banner Mobile Piano Exit Overlay Banner Desktop