Letters archive
Join the conversation in Âé¶¹´«Ã½'s Letters section, where readers can share their thoughts and opinions on articles and see responses from experts and enthusiasts across a range of science topics. To submit a letter, please see our terms and email letters@newscientist.com
11 December 2019
From Steve Snow, Edale, Derbyshire, UK
You ask whether it is "dewy-eyed idealism" to imagine international research institutions dedicated to climate change, modelled on CERN ( Leader, 23 November ). It would indeed be dewy-eyed to suggest that scientists are inherently more tolerant and cooperative than anyone else. Accelerators large enough to push the frontiers of physics are fantastically expensive. Particle …
11 December 2019
From Ian Shardlow, Lichfield, Staffordshire, UK
Abigail Beall offers tips for observing meteor showers ( 16 November, p 51 ). I would like to share an alternative way to see them that works when it is cloudy and even in daylight. There is a very powerful space surveillance radar station in France called GRAVES . When a meteor burns up, the …
11 December 2019
From Paul Bowden, Nottingham, UK
Donna Lu describes an artificial intelligence system that can detect problems in electrocardiograms and predict early death ( 16 November, p 19 ). The system can do this despite there being no clues in the data that cardiologists can pick up on. This situation highlights a major problem with deep-learning neural net systems. They may …
11 December 2019
From Paul Whiteley, Bittaford, Devon, UK
A reflex will pull your hand away from a flame. It is our ability to know this has happened that means we know we are conscious. When an artificial intelligence system makes a prediction that someone will die in the next 12 months, but neither it nor its programmers knows how it has come to …
11 December 2019
From Peter Nettleton, Edinburgh, UK
The use of mosquito nets for fishing can have destructive consequences for food security and coastal ecosystems by the removal of juvenile fish, as Brian Owens reports ( 16 November, p 9 ). The pyrethroid insecticides that are often used to treat the nets pose a further threat. They are highly toxic to aquatic insects, …
18 December 2019
From Robert Willis, Nanaimo, British Columbia, Canada
Your review of the exhibition Flop: 13 stories of failure reminded me of finding Stephen Pile's wonderful 1979 tome The Book of Heroic Failures ( 9 November, p 31 ). Its guiding principle was that anyone can succeed, but it takes genius to fail in spectacular ways. The notion that great success can come from …
18 December 2019
From Jeremy Cook, London, UK
As a neuroscientist who identifies the concept of "me" with a subset of the complex activities in my all-too-mortal brain, I have no problem accepting the notion of "not-being" after my death . As a former embryology teacher, I also had to consider the conundrum, which Lawton mentions in passing, of my "not-being" for aeons …
18 December 2019
From Roger Taylor, Meols, Wirral, UK
We still have to do everything, immediately, to fix climate change, says Graham Lawton, but at least we aren't doing nothing ( 9 November, p 22 ). The other day, I drifted into a casual discussion about climate change with a friend who turned out to be a denier. It demonstrated that neither of us …
18 December 2019
From Simon Evans, Malvern, Worcestershire, UK
Fred White likens the climate crisis to an iceberg towards which we, like the Titanic, are heading (Letters, 23 November ). To extend this metaphor: we are metres away from that iceberg and the ship's wheel is broken. For every positive step we take to limit emissions, we slither backwards by electing a Donald Trump …