Âé¶¹´«Ã½

Letters archive

Join the conversation in Âé¶¹´«Ã½'s Letters section, where readers can share their thoughts and opinions on articles and see responses from experts and enthusiasts across a range of science topics. To submit a letter, please see our terms and email letters@newscientist.com


13 November 2019

Editor's pick: Let's confront some causes of domestic violence

From Bonita Ely, Sydney, Australia

Alice Klein discusses the prevalence and prevention of domestic violence and the treatment of victims and perpetrators ( 19 October, p 20 ). Another aspect worth mentioning is the effect of post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) on behaviour. As Joshua Goldstein writes in War and Gender , PTSD typically leads to emotional numbing, recurrent nightmares, substance …

13 November 2019

A few solutions to the minimoon conundrum (1)

From Brian Horton, West Launceston, Tasmania, Australia

Leah Crane argues that 214 moons is too many for a solar system because some are just rocks ( 26 October, p 23 ). She suggests we only include satellites that are large enough to be roughly spherical: 400 to 600 kilometres in diameter. This limit would remove Phobos and Deimos, at 22 km and …

13 November 2019

A few solutions to the minimoon conundrum (2)

From Bryn Glover, Kirkby Malzeard, North Yorkshire, UK

Things are getting out of hand with the number of moons in our solar system, says Crane. Perhaps she could go one step further than redefining moons and consider the well-established example of binary stars as a model. Why not binary planets? The moons Ganymede and Titan are bigger than Mercury. If they occupied independent …

13 November 2019

Our examples of thinking without language (1)

From Brian Josephson, Cambridge, UK

According to David Werdegar, "a composer may internally hear a melody, hum the tune and have a second person hum it too (Letters, 26 October ). But developing it for an instrument or an entire orchestra requires much thought, and that thought requires language." That contrasts with my own experience composing Sweet and Sour Harmony …

13 November 2019

For the record – 16 November 2019

• Carbon dioxide emissions from human activities are estimated at about 35 billion tonnes of carbon per year ( 5 October, p 34 ). • One song of the white bellbird ( Procnias albus ) measures 116 dB(a) at a distance of 1 metre ( 26 October, p 9 ).

20 November 2019

The other side of that whale of a tale, Moby-Dick

From Derek Till, Bedford, Massachusetts, US

Chris Simms reviews Ahab's Rolling Sea: A natural history of Moby-Dick ( 19 October, p 28 ). The sinking of the Nantucket whaler Essex by a large whale in the Pacific in 1820 is generally regarded as inspiration for Moby-Dick . Its author, Herman Melville, was friendly with the first mate, Owen Chace, and knew …

20 November 2019

Surely giraffes' necks must confer some advantage

From Anthony Wheeler, Mackay, Queensland, Australia

Derek Bolton mentions Daniel Milo's assertion that giraffes' long necks have no significant advantages (Letters, 14 September, p 27 ). On the contrary, the length of their necks allows them to drink water on the ground, but only just. Giraffes have to splay their front legs to get their mouth low enough to drink, which …

20 November 2019

Use and prefiguration of a steered aerial bathyscaphe (1)

From Bernie Hanning, Calonge, Girona, Spain

I have been following for some time the progress of Alan Handley's Varialift project, reported by Donna Lu ( 12 October, p 15 ). The Varialift is an aerial bathyscaphe, able to perform highly accurate and maintainable altitudes. I believe the most important use for it will be in disaster relief. Delivering basic supplies in …

20 November 2019

Use and prefiguration of a steered aerial bathyscaphe (2)

From Sandy Henderson, Dunblane, Stirling, UK

Lu mentions exploiting the buoyancy of an airship to propel it by storing compressed air and using it for thrust. Your columnist Daedalus ( David E. H. Jones, 1938-2017 ) had a more elegant solution with his thermal "glidoon" ( 17 February 1972, p 400 ). He proposed effecting buoyancy change through the condensation of …

20 November 2019

We would all be the poorer without Âé¶¹´«Ã½

From Jill Dempsey, Small Dole, West Sussex, UK

Like your letter writers Andrea Needham and Marcus Swann , my first reaction to the series of adverts by BP in Âé¶¹´«Ã½ was "they shouldn't be publishing these" (Letters, 2 November ). On reflection, if Âé¶¹´«Ã½ doesn't get funded from advertising, we will all be the poorer as it will cease to exist. …

Sign up to our weekly newsletter

Receive a weekly dose of discovery in your inbox. We'll also keep you up to date with Âé¶¹´«Ã½ events and special offers.

Sign up
Piano Exit Overlay Banner Mobile Piano Exit Overlay Banner Desktop