Âé¶¹´«Ã½

Letters archive

Join the conversation in Âé¶¹´«Ã½'s Letters section, where readers can share their thoughts and opinions on articles and see responses from experts and enthusiasts across a range of science topics. To submit a letter, please see our terms and email letters@newscientist.com


16 April 2019

Your piece on the school strike gives me hope

From Ellen Okamura, Austin, Texas, US

I've grown up reading my father's copies of Âé¶¹´«Ã½ , and as a student at the University of Texas at Austin, I have been learning about oceanography and the effects of climate change. I was delighted to read about the youth of the world coming together to combat the detrimental actions that have been …

16 April 2019

Population replacement may have been different (1)

From Cathryn Iliffe, Bradford, West Yorkshire, UK

Colin Barras reports work on the spread of Yamnaya culture from the Eurasian steppes ( 30 March, p 29 ). In the UK, the people who built Stonehenge probably left a genetic legacy. Studies show an influx of DNA from 2450 BC, after which Yamnaya DNA varied from 60 to 100 per cent between individuals. …

16 April 2019

Population replacement may have been different (2)

From Erik Kroon, Leiden, The Netherlands

I was most pleased to see my field of study – Corded Ware culture – featured on your cover. But the mention of genocide and "Stone Age conquerors" is, to my mind, overstating the evidence. Migration is no doubt a factor in the changes observed in the third millennium BC in Europe, but that doesn't …

16 April 2019

Population replacement may have been different (3)

From Robert Bright, Bedford, UK

Some questions sprang to mind about the spread of the livestock herders called the Yamnaya. Where does this name come from? Barras refers to some of the Yamnaya travelling to the Indian subcontinent. Is this perhaps the origin of the Indo-European family of languages? The editor writes: • The name is from "Yamnaya Kultura", a …

16 April 2019

Yet another odd reason for removing teeth

From Crispin Piney, Mougins, France

Terrance Chapman doesn't know the reason for his mother-in-law's total tooth removal in the 1930s (Letters, 16 March ) and Aroha Mahoney says a neighbour's were removed in the 1950s to save her husband money (Letters, 6 April ). My father, who suffered the same fate in the early 1900s, explained that this treatment was …

16 April 2019

Greens with a side of poisonous arsenic

From Aidan Karley, Brechin, Angus, UK

So a species of caterpillar happily dines on arsenic-loaded leaves ( 16 March, p 20 ). I recall how a suggestion that microbes could substitute arsenic for phosphorus in their biochemistry ( 26 April 2008, p 10 ) caused a mild furore and then rebuttals ( 28 January 2012, p 6 ). Wouldn't such caterpillars …

16 April 2019

Size matters for our friends' quantum views

From Nick Canning, Coleraine, County Londonderry, UK

You draw the conclusion that alternative facts are real from a paradox, which arises from a thought experiment about the states of friends of observers of a quantum event ( 2 March, p 7 ). This would only be true if we accepted that an unambiguously quantum object such as a single photon can be …

16 April 2019

We probably can't smell the presence of one gene

From Richard Harris, Ottawa, Canada

Geoff Convery suggests that cystic fibrosis carriers might recognise each other through olfaction (Letters, 2 March ). But cystic fibrosis is caused by a mutation in a single gene. It seems extremely unlikely that one mutated gene among tens of thousands would be detectable by smell.

16 April 2019

For the record – 20 April 2019

• However it may be discovered that functional disorders arise, there is no suggestion that it is through conscious thinking ( 6 April, p 28 ). • The philosopher Daniel Dennett popularised the word "sphexish" to describe rigidly-determined behaviours, but did not coin it ( 6 April, p 34 ).

Sign up to our weekly newsletter

Receive a weekly dose of discovery in your inbox. We'll also keep you up to date with Âé¶¹´«Ã½ events and special offers.

Sign up
Piano Exit Overlay Banner Mobile Piano Exit Overlay Banner Desktop