Letters archive
Join the conversation in Âé¶¹´«Ã½'s Letters section, where readers can share their thoughts and opinions on articles and see responses from experts and enthusiasts across a range of science topics. To submit a letter, please see our terms and email letters@newscientist.com
9 January 2019
From Jane Rawson, Footscray, Victoria, Australia
Thank you for your seven steps to save the planet ( 8 December 2018, p 31 ). I would have found it even more useful if it had contained a list of the barriers to achieving each step and how we might overcome them. Barriers to killing oil, gas and coal, for a start, include …
9 January 2019
From Barry Cash, Bristol, UK
Olive Heffernan says that leaders such as President Macron of France need to find some backbone, confronted with climate change and the ' gilets jaunes ' opposition to his tax rises ( 15 December 2018, p 26 ). But why did Macron start by taxing the transport that the least well-off depend on? Surely it …
9 January 2019
From Keith Hodgkinson, East Leake, Nottinghamshire, UK
Your piece on the handprints of the prehistoric artists of Gargas and Cosquer caves offered several possible explanations for the missing digits ( 8 December 2018, p 16 ). None of these reflected my experience when teaching young schoolchildren to paint their own cave animals. While painting with their right hand, several children held a …
9 January 2019
From David Muir, Edinburgh, UK
Michael Marshall discusses hypotheses on absent fingers in Stone Age cave art. Perhaps there is a simpler explanation. The ubiquitous practice of flint-knapping would have resulted in many injured and infected fingers. Rather than risk blood poisoning or gangrene, those with severely damaged digits could have amputated them with a newly knapped tool. So before …
9 January 2019
From Andy Taylor, Edinburgh, UK
Chelsea Whyte weighs up the pros and cons of meal kits ( 8 December 2018, p 22 ). She does not mention one quite significant drawback: the transport costs of getting these kits to people's houses. Presumably most are delivered in small or medium, diesel-fuelled vans. Many of these will be nearly empty, especially when …
9 January 2019
From Sanya Sanderson, Wirral, UK
Alice Klein highlights a study suggesting little difference between the environmental footprints of washable and disposable nappies ( 24 November 2018, p 22 ). I suspect this underestimated the average journey of a washable nappy and the commitment of those who use them. In the 1960s, my mother used terry nappies with my brother and …
9 January 2019
From Brian Collins, Wellington, New Zealand
Douglas Heaven reports that a prototype aeroplane using electroaerodynamic propulsion flew for 12 seconds, the same as the Wright brothers achieved with their maiden flight ( 24 November 2018, p 7 ). It is a historical fact that the Wright brothers flew their bird-like monoplane on 17 December 1903. But many believe that New Zealander …
9 January 2019
From Robert Masta, Ann Arbor, Michigan, US
Alice Klein and Chelsea Whyte say that switching Christmas lights to static rather than flashing mode uses less power ( 1 December 2018, p 22 ). This is true of incandescent lights, which draw high "inrush" current when the filaments are cold and have low resistance. But LED lights have no comparable phenomenon. Their energy …