Letters archive
Join the conversation in Âé¶¹´«Ã½'s Letters section, where readers can share their thoughts and opinions on articles and see responses from experts and enthusiasts across a range of science topics. To submit a letter, please see our terms and email letters@newscientist.com
25 July 2018
From Douglas Maynard, Blackboys, East Sussex, UK
Michael Harrison suggests that neural networks should have a "don't know" output (Letters, 30 June ). If he visits the mathematics gallery of the Science Museum in London he will find the London Hospital Survival Predictor , which I invented in 1972. It used two "classifiers" on electroencephalograph data from patients in a coma after …
25 July 2018
From Stephanie Woodcock, Carnon Downs, Cornwall, UK
Clare Wilson is not entirely convinced by Edward Bullmore's argument in The Inflamed Mind that mental adversity causes inflammation, which then causes depression ( 30 June, p 46 ). Our bodies may be facing many potential hidden stressors, so I wonder why emphasis is placed on psychological stress as the most important driver of the …
25 July 2018
From Jackie Jones, Brighton, East Sussex, UK
Researcher Frédéric Lechenault concludes that the stretchiness of knitting is due to the way interlocked stitches spread friction through the fabric, based on an assumption that the yarn itself doesn't stretch ( 30 June, p 19 ). Perhaps he should watch someone knit a scarf. Depending on what pattern of stitch a knitter uses, they …
25 July 2018
From Iain Murdoch, Marton, Warwickshire, UK
Peter Wilson is enthusiastic about electric aircraft ( 30 June, p 24 ). But one problem they face is that an empty battery weighs just as much as a full one, whereas a liquid-fuelled plane gets lighter and more efficient as its tanks empty. So can we jettison empty batteries and recover them? I recall …
25 July 2018
From Eric Kvaalen, Les Essarts-le-Roi, France
What Wilson fails to mention is that the heavier the plane , the more energy it takes to get from A to B because more lift is needed and there is more drag. About half the weight of a liquid-fuelled long-range flight at take-off is fuel. We need instead to develop liquid fuel that doesn't …
25 July 2018
From William Cole, Bishops Stortford, Hertfordshire, UK
Your encouragement in one issue to think about both consciousness ( 30 June, p 30 ) and Schrödinger's cat ( p 34 ) raises interesting questions. When Schrödinger originally formulated his conundrum, he postulated that a single conscious entity making an observation would determine the fate of his poor entrapped moggy. Subsequently the conundrum was …
25 July 2018
From Chris Evans, Earby, Lancashire, UK
Schrödinger's cat is one of the great non-questions. Anyone who has ever owned (or rather been staff for) a cat will know that it is conscious and self-aware, so would be perfectly capable of collapsing the wave function itself. Maybe it would be worth discussing "Schrödinger's bacterium"?
25 July 2018
From Celia Berrell, Cairns, Queensland, Australia
Rob Bayly asks why you don't post Âé¶¹´«Ã½ in a paper pack and you say you are reviewing this (Letters, 23 June ). I live in the tropical far north of Queensland in Australia, and look forward to seeing my magazine each week in the mailbox at the end of our drive. During the …