Letters archive
Join the conversation in Âé¶¹´«Ã½'s Letters section, where readers can share their thoughts and opinions on articles and see responses from experts and enthusiasts across a range of science topics. To submit a letter, please see our terms and email letters@newscientist.com
11 April 2018
From Alastair Mouat, Biggar, South Lanarkshire, UK
You report on a genetically engineered yeast that makes a beer taste of hops without the need for hops ( 24 March, p 19 ). Is it possible that the cost of producing such a yeast would be as great as the cost of using hops? In any case, the greatest cost element in producing …
11 April 2018
From Robert Proctor, Ballarat, Victoria, Australia
Clare Wilson discusses the controversy over the effectiveness of antidepressants ( 3 March, p 27 ). As a psychiatrist with more than 40 years' experience, I am surprised the debate still rages. In psychiatric and research communities, there is total agreement that antidepressants are an incredibly valuable intervention in the treatment of major depression. Not …
11 April 2018
From Julie Richards, Basingstoke, Hampshire, UK
You discuss how the gender pay gap permeates science and engineering ( 3 March, p 5 and p 22 ). It is important to highlight and address pay disparity – and it is also important not to confuse equal pay and the gender pay gap. Consider eight female and two male science employees, each earning …
11 April 2018
From Daniel Hackett, London, UK
Colin Barras's article on the domestication of humans highlights genetic similarities to domesticated animals and says these may have arisen because tameness helped human cooperation and hence boosted survival ( 24 February, p 28 ). But what happens if environmental conditions change so that "feral/caveman" characteristics are favoured once again? After a pandemic, loners might …
11 April 2018
From Heather Brindley, Canberra, Australia
Human self-domestication made for a very interesting article. But perhaps the word "gracile" would be a better description of the relatively lighter build of domesticated species. The word "feminine" comes with a lot of human-specific cultural baggage.
11 April 2018
From Peter Daymond-King, Helensville, New Zealand
I do not find the idea that our ancestors domesticated themselves very convincing. After all, wolves learned to cooperate in a pack without showing signs of self-domestication. I wonder whether our ancestors were domesticated by Neanderthals and that our predilection towards inventing gods "in our own image" is a memory of this.
11 April 2018
From Ray Reed, Basingstoke, Hampshire, UK
Danny Chambers advises the abolition of electric dog training collars ( 10 March, p 24 ). Should he not include electric stock fences?
11 April 2018
From Andrew Sanderson, Spennymoor, County Durham, UK
Julian Smith describes the ecological disasters generated by digging sand for use in concrete ( 17 February, p 35 ). These are only part of the story. Manufacture of cement causes around 5 per cent of carbon dioxide emissions .