Letters archive
Join the conversation in Âé¶¹´«Ã½'s Letters section, where readers can share their thoughts and opinions on articles and see responses from experts and enthusiasts across a range of science topics. To submit a letter, please see our terms and email letters@newscientist.com
14 May 2025
From Bernd-Juergen Fischer, Berlin, Germany
You say there is no clear reason why the behaviour of subatomic particles can't be governed by deterministic laws, and the fact that they aren't demands an explanation( 19 April, p 28 ). Well, here is one: we are working our way down the chain of causality. This will either end or it won't. If …
14 May 2025
From Nick Rowden, Liverpool, UK
Could the ancient Greeks have invented quantum theory? While a full-blown version probably couldn't have been formulated much earlier than it was, all you would need to postulate a sort of quantum theory would be to assume that nothing in the real world can be infinite. This probably isn't an unreasonable assumption. After all, if …
14 May 2025
From Richard Ellam, Bristol, UK
You report on suggestions that the Antikythera mechanism didn't function. Over the past 70 years or so, a number of distinguished and skilful historians and museum curators have conclusively established, by making physical replicas of the mechanism, that it did function. Thanks to their work, we now have a pretty good idea of what it …
14 May 2025
From Richard Bradford, Chesterfield, Derbyshire, UK
The younger generation may or may not be as intelligent as their elders, but their lives are markedly different. Entwined with digital devices, can they fully appreciate the real world? If not, how will they be able to cope with the realities and uncertainties of life? I take pains to remind my students in their …
21 May 2025
From Maggie Wiśniewska, Shoreline, Washington, US
For decades, scientists searched for a bright line separating human culture from "mere" animal behaviour. The more evidence we get, the fainter that line becomes. When we insist on judging every other species against the single yardstick of human society, we reveal more about our biases than we do about other animals( 5 April, p …
21 May 2025
From Meredith Lloyd-Evans, Duxford, Cambridgeshire, UK
Bethan Ackerley asked for a climate change TV drama that can make a big impact. There may not be one, but there is Jonathan Dove's new opera, Uprising , inspired by Greta Thunberg's story. It has a tremendous impact that leaves many audiences and quite a few community chorus members crying at the end, including …
21 May 2025
From Sam Edge, Ringwood, Hampshire, UK
I agree with Paul Holt on the need to control for factors affecting dementia rates other than school leaving age before and after 1972. But I would be cautious before assuming that the older cohort who were born and brought up during rationing, and their mothers, were more likely to be malnourished. Many studies suggest …
21 May 2025
From Robert Masta, Ann Arbor, Michigan, US
Last year, Matt Strassler explained that particles are really a kind of wave ( 21 September 2024, p 32 ). Now, Celso Villas-Boas says that no, they are really just particles after all( 3 May, p 8 ). Arguments are traditionally settled with a duel. Electron guns at 20 paces? Or a more modern cage …
21 May 2025
From Dave Shipley, Ottawa, Ontario, Canada
I learned from you that dark chocolate is high in fibre. That fact by itself has made this year's subscription worth the money. I salute you, Graham Lawton, with a square of 70 per cent cacao( 12 April, p 34 ).